On the surface it's a short article about some protesters, but in the hands of the CBC its so much more..“Jordan Peterson was forced to cancel a speaking engagement this week after two speakers at the event said protesters hurled racial slurs at the mostly South Asian attendees. Peterson stayed away from the event and spoke via zoom for three minutes. He said no one should be intimidated or stopped from exercising their democratic freedoms “because that's what this country is all about.”.OK, it wasn't Jordan Peterson; it was Trudeau., but the absurdity is clear. This kind of parade follows Peterson wherever he goes, at least in Canada, and we can't imagine him canceling because of some “slurs”. Our prime minister, though? Trudeau senior would have “hurled” the slurs right back..The CBC account reveals a lot more than a prime minister who rejects conversation. It shows how bold our legacy media manipulation can be..One often overlooked fact is vital: In the vast array of potential stories to be covered on that day, this one was chosen. The writer — or whomever cut and pasted it from the Canadian Press — could have gone in many different directions, but this is the result. The details were selected for many reasons, but its naïve to assume it's here to benevolently inform the public, especially when the politician being covered in the story is the one paying the journalist's salary..News and those who tell it benefit from the news they tell. Just as advertising influences the news, so too does government — whoever is doling out more, and this relationship has to be sustained..News is never just facts: its always interpretation. At best what we see we record in words, which are symbols, and in so doing we shrink reality into a transmissible form to be shared across a channel. Its that shrinking that makes it interpretation. We will never hear the symphony that Beethoven heard in his own head, and we will never see what that reporter actually saw. We have to, literally, take their words for it..And they have lots to choose from. The reporter can use heavy-handed, militaristic language, like “hurl” and “targeted” rather than “voiced” or “directed." The reader gets a picture of catapults and bull's eyes — unless, like me, you had the surrealist picture of protesters vomiting “hurling” up their “slurs.”.For some media, its only environmentalist protesters who are granted “chant” instead of “hurl.” “Racist slur” is easier than “unkind words that seemed to have a racial bent to them,” and though the messier term is probably more accurate, we all nod in virtuous grim-faced agreement like we know exactly what “racist slur” is, though we don't have a clue, and they won't define it for us..The appearance of impartiality is, of course, important. Represent the speaker in context, and have quotes from both sides. But, its up to the journalist to decide not only who gets the balance of quotations, but what those quotations are..In the Surrey article “'We don't like the way he is running Canada', is sum total voice of the protesters. Out of four dozen protesters, this is the one quotation the reporter gleaned. He or she covered the bases, though, and technically “showed both sides”. We are left to assume apart from this one line, it was all “expletives” and “racial slurs.”.Heroes and villains? They're here, too. Two weeks ago the hero was Jagmeet Singh when he was heckled in Peterborough while walking to a nearby security vehicle..Now, the Surrey story shows an equally put-upon leader: “Trudeau was forced to cancel” his speaking engagement, we are told. Were security personnel consulted in this reporting? Had they advised the prime minister about this threat? Nope. Straight conjecture. Meanwhile, he speaks for all Canadians, this hero. No one should be stopped from exercising their democratic freedoms, he said, “because that's what this country is all about." How is it that Trudeau, slinking back to a zoom room can possibly come out as noble? The writer tells us that our prime minister had no choice and that the protesters strong-armed him into leaving. Poor guy..Villains are here, too. Though Ethics 101 says the media should not assign unearned goodness or badness to one side, we are in the thick of it here: one group that's diverse, intelligent, thoughtful individuals and another who speak as an ignorant faceless mob, without nuance, without personal and unique reasons and motives, without children at home. It's in-group/out-grouping. Reasonable liberals don't hurl. Ignorant angry right-wing conservative mobs do..So, bits from a given event have been chosen over others and then connected so as to lend a certain interpretation. Its framing. What frame do we adopt here? Canadians can't talk anymore? Trudeau is a wimp? Don't go to Surrey? Perhaps the classic “disruption frame” where the protesters are upsetting the lives of people who have nothing to do with them? These innocents can't go on with their daily lives, in this case a fundraising dinner..My vote is for “Angry racist protesters hate food banks.” Look at the top of the piece: there you see the picture of a food bank and men in turbans speaking thoughtfully with our prime minister ... though there's nothing about a food bank in the story. Normally we would ask what its doing there, but framing has helped make the connections..Sometimes other unrelated or only slightly related stories are added to create a frame. Take a story of a pastor who bucked pandemic restrictions and link a story to a church where there was an outbreak, for example. It's clustering. In the Surrey article, the final four paragraphs of the old Jagmeet story are added along with two hypertext links to other CBC articles. The first link reads: “'Prime minister says communities have 'right to be angry'” after tense appearance at Kamloops memorial.” We assume that the anger will be at the protesters, but that's not it at all: its actually indigenous anger at the government and the revelation of unmarked graves. The anger has nothing to do with the Surrey protesters, but it sticks, as does — here it comes — Trudeau's warning about “right-wing terrorism” at the Kamloops event. Red herring? Distraction?.The second hypertext link reads, “Police arrest suspect of allegedly vandalized Komagata Maru memorial in Vancouver.” We've got a picture of the suspect already — he's male, racist, and probably a trucker or biker. When arrested he undoubtedly hurled a bunch of stuff, too. He was probably one of these protesters..“The memorial 'acknowledges a racial chapter in Canada's history,'” says the article, and the graffiti initially was considered as a hate crime. A critical reader should ask: What does someone vandalizing a memorial have to do with protesters angry at Trudeau? Are they synonymous?.So a bunch of otherwise seemingly unrelated articles are clustered together and we are lead to an assumption about faceless, voiceless protesters. Precedent and character are cemented: racial slur hurling is a regular feature at anti-Trudeau/Singh protests. Truckers. Jagmeet protesters. Trudeau protesters. These people hate South Asians. They swear. They deface monuments. They make even blackbelts in Jiujitsu feel unsafe..In a healthy democracy the journalist is not supposed to be the voice of the government..Every tyrant needs a scapegoat. We are in for a season of more protests, and more demonizing of them. Again, Trudeau will continue to cancel conversations, and he will not be held to account for it: he has no choice, after all. Racial minorities will be used for political gain. He will duck and dodge, and it will be the fault of those who are voicing their grievances, which will never be unpacked at any length by our media..The worst taboos of our society have been laid on them. Protesters are dangerous, and we should fear them. They are numbers, not people. They don't speak like humans; they hurl..We have a cliché for them, too: “right-wing extremists.”