New legislation introduced in the Senate would allow RCMP officers and federal prosecutors to enforce First Nations laws and bylaws, addressing long-standing concerns about a lack of recognition for indigenous justice systems by mainstream legal authorities.Sen. Mary Jane McCallum (Manitoba) tabled two bills to amend the Director of Public Prosecutions Act — without public comment. Both would formally authorize enforcement of First Nations legislation, a step advocates say is necessary to strengthen self-governance.Blacklock's Reporter says a recent Department of Justice report emphasized the uniqueness of First Nations’ legal systems and the ongoing difficulty in getting them recognized by provincial courts, governments, and police. .“One of the greatest challenges… is the lack of recognition of First Nations laws and bylaws by provincial governments and courts, the federal government, external police services and even sometimes the nations’ community members,” said the report, What We Learned: Discussions With Four First Nations About The Administration And Enforcement Of Their Laws And Bylaws.The report was based on consultations with the Tsawwassen First Nation (B.C.), Tsuut’ina Nation (Alberta), Whitecap Dakota Nation (Saskatchewan), and Mohawks of Akwesasne (Québec), all of which emphasized that Indigenous justice needs vary widely between communities.While the proposed bills mark a step toward formal recognition, public opinion remains mixed. A 2024 Department of Justice survey found that only 45% of Canadians support the idea of Indigenous people administering their own legal systems. .Support was significantly higher among indigenous respondents, with 70% of First Nations and 57% of Métis in favor, compared to 44% of white respondents.Meanwhile, safety challenges remain a serious concern. A 2022 Department of Public Safety study found that violent crime in First Nations and Inuit communities was nine times higher than the national average, with domestic violence rates 16 times higher. The report also noted that indigenous women face violent victimization rates double those of Indigenous men and nearly triple those of non-Indigenous women.
