GWYN MORGAN: Mark Carney’s fiscal fantasy will bankrupt Canada

Gwyn Morgan is a retired business leader who was a director of five global corporationsMark Carney was supposed to be the adult in the room. After nearly a decade of runaway spending under Justin Trudeau, the former central banker was presented to Canadians as a steady hand — someone who could responsibly manage the economy and restore fiscal discipline.Instead, Carney has taken Trudeau’s recklessness and dialled it up. His government’s recently released spending plan shows an increase of 8.5 per cent this fiscal year to $437.8 billion. Add in “non-budgetary spending” such as EI payouts, plus at least $49 billion just to service the burgeoning national debt and total spending in Carney’s first year in office will hit $554.5 billion. Even if tax revenues were to remain level with last year — and they almost certainly won’t, given the tariff wars ravaging Canadian industry — we are hurtling toward a deficit that could easily exceed three per cent of GDP, and thus dwarf our meagre annual economic growth. It will only get worse. The Parliamentary Budget Officer estimates debt interest alone will consume $70 billion annually by 2029. Fitch Ratings recently warned of Canada’s “rapid and steep fiscal deterioration,” noting that if the Liberal program is implemented total federal, provincial and local debt would rise to 90 per cent of GDP..This was already a fiscal powder keg. But then Carney casually tossed in a lit match. At June’s NATO summit, he pledged to raise defence spending to two per cent of GDP this fiscal year — to roughly $62 billion. Days later, he stunned even his own caucus by promising to match NATO’s new five per cent target. If he and his Liberal colleagues follow through, Canada’s defence spending will balloon to the current annual equivalent of $155 billion per year. There is no plan to pay for this. It will all go on the national credit card.This is not “responsible government.” It is economic madness.And it’s happening amid broader economic decline. Business investment per worker — a key driver of productivity and living standards — has been shrinking since 2015. The C.D. Howe Institute warns that Canadian workers are increasingly “under-equipped compared to their peers abroad,” making us less competitive and less prosperous.The problem isn’t a lack of money; it’s a lack of discipline and vision. We’ve created a business climate that punishes investment: high taxes, sluggish regulatory processes, and politically motivated uncertainty. Carney has done nothing to reverse this. If anything, he’s making the situation worse..Recall the 2008 global financial meltdown. Carney loves to highlight his role as Bank of Canada Governor during that time but the true credit for steering the country through the crisis belongs to then-prime minister Stephen Harper and his finance minister, Jim Flaherty. Facing the pressures of a minority parliament, they made the tough decisions that safeguarded Canada’s fiscal foundation. Their disciplined governance is something Carney would do well to emulate.Instead, he’s tearing down that legacy. His recent $4.3 billion aid pledge to Ukraine, made without parliamentary approval, exemplifies his careless approach. And his self-proclaimed image as the experienced technocrat who could go eyeball-to-eyeball against Trump is starting to crack. Instead of respecting Carney, Trump is almost toying with him, announcing in June, for example that the U.S. would pull out of the much-ballyhooed bilateral trade talks launched at the G7 Summit less than two weeks earlier..Ordinary Canadians will foot the bill for Carney’s fiscal mess. The dollar has weakened. Young Canadians — already priced out of the housing market — will inherit a mountain of debt. This is not stewardship. It’s generational theft.Some still believe Carney will pivot — that he will eventually govern sensibly. But nothing in his actions supports that hope. A leader serious about economic renewal would cancel wasteful Trudeau-era programs, streamline approvals for energy and resource projects, and offer incentives for capital investment. Instead, we’re getting more borrowing and ideological showmanship.It’s no longer credible to say Carney is better than Trudeau. He’s worse. Trudeau at least pretended deficits were temporary. Carney has made them permanent — and more dangerous.This is a betrayal of the fiscal stability Canadians were promised. If we care about our credit rating, our standard of living, or the future we are leaving our children, we must change course. That begins by removing a government unwilling — or unable — to do the job.Canada once set an economic example for others. Those days are gone. The warning signs — soaring debt, declining productivity, and diminished global standing — are everywhere. Carney’s defenders may still hope he can grow into the job. Canada cannot afford to wait and find out. Gwyn Morgan is a retired business leader who was a director of five global corporations. The original, full-length version of this article was recently published in C2C Journal.

GWYN MORGAN: Mark Carney’s fiscal fantasy will bankrupt Canada

Related Stories

KAPLAN: The $10-to-$1 dilemma in Alberta

KAPLAN: Beyond the referendum — Alberta's next fight for fiscal fairness

Federal debt interest costs double to $59.3 billion as Carney spending exceeds budget

KAPLAN: Albertans could send $900 billion more to Ottawa than receive back over the next 25 years