They're talking about forgiveness! What's a cynical Christian to do?.Remember this past July? Remember the Pope's 'penitential pilgrimage,' when the Holy Father asked for forgiveness for the Catholic Church's part in administering the Indian Residential schools, and for the church's 'colonialist' heritage?.Across our media, every time someone pushed back against the Pope's apology, it seemed there was a 'let's-front-page-this!' reaction. Thus, for example, images such as that of the tearful Indigenous woman who sang a song to the tune of 'O Canada,' who said later that she was 'rebuking' the Pope. The non-forgiveness was everywhere..And while the Pope sought to right the wrongs, did any moral Canadian in the media or the church — or even those who truly had an axe to grind without the aid of the priggish cancel-culture cartel — think the Pope was seeking exemption from reparations? From accountability?.He was not. But when you turn to making sense of COVID-19, you find a request for forgiveness, without the crucial admission of guilt that must come before it..For example, you've perhaps read Emily Oster's article in The Atlantic, “Let's Declare a Pandemic Amnesty.”.Oster, an economics professor, writes, “We need to forgive each other for what we did and said when we were in the dark about COVID.”.She tells us we should “focus on the future.”.She says, “We didn't know,” and that “Keeping score keeps us from moving forward.”.She says that “dwelling on the past can doom us to failure” and that people were “working in earnest for the good of society.”.She says, “Getting something wrong wasn't a moral failing.”.I read the article with my mouth agape..I'm all for forgiving. Goodness knows, my guts have had enough of the anger. But Oster — who cites the benefits of the mRNA vaccines, and had her family mask up while hiking, must have missed a little of what many others went through, for example like those who write in the Western Standard's own Comments section, “I will never forgive.”. Emily OsterEmily Oster .Its weirdly pre-emptive, this call to forgive and move on..Even before any acknowledgment of harm and abuse and indeed any real naming of what it is we are to forgive, we are pressed with the call for amnesty. It's like the Pope taking to the airwaves to pre-empt the Truth and Reconciliation Committee. And in a way, it does a kind of violence: No, no. You weren't truly harmed, because people were trying their best..But sceptical readers of The Atlantic article are likely niggled by something else — in this case, something that's not here: Penitence..Don't we also expect at least a little contrition on the part of the person seeking forgiveness? Like the wayward son in the story of the prodigal, who returns begging for forgiveness and expects to be treated as no better than a servant?.But Oster's forgiveness is with neither penitence nor acknowledgment. Yet “in order to receive forgiveness,” says writer and pastor Douglas Wilson, “you have to name the sin. You have to name the problem.”.So, its like Oster's let's-let-bygones-be-bygones pitch isn't based on anything real. It rests on nothing and in fact, has far less to rest on after COVID than before..When I as a Christian think of forgiveness, it is based on the belief that something (or someOne) is in the space between me and that other person who is asking me for forgiveness. This is not a self-help thing. This is not a, “Well it would be nice to let the other guy off because he had a bad upbringing” thing. I have been forgiven for my sins, God calls me to forgive, and the person I hope to emulate — even in small measure, is forgiveness personified..But when today's secular regime appropriates any Christian practice they mess it up. It's a post-COVID, woke world, and forgiveness is hard to come by. Why indeed should I forgive if right and wrong is only a product of a wrongly constructed society — why should I forgive when I have neither needed or been given forgiveness? Ms. Oster, the medium is the message, and the heavy-handed, machine-like medium since Februay 2020 has fostered nothing remotely resembling a coming together at a table of brotherly love. There has been no table, and certainly no love. Only computer modelling, sanitizer, masks, case counts, and authority..“Forgiveness can only happen with God's help,” said the Pope last summer, pilgrimaging in his wheelchair to try and right some very real wrongs..That is what it will take. Without Him, moving on is going nowhere..Therefore, let's have the conversation.